WTI Crude--
Brent Crude--
Natural Gas--
ND Rig Count--
WTI Crude--
Brent Crude--
Natural Gas--
ND Rig Count--
ND PSC Attorney Says Safety Not a Factor in State Pipeline Permitting - Bakken Wire
Pipeline & Infrastructure

ND PSC Attorney Says Safety Not a Factor in State Pipeline Permitting

Hearing on Summit Carbon Solutions permit appeal reveals state's limited regulatory role, raising questions for future Bakken infrastructure projects.

Bakken Wire Staff·☀️Morning Wire·

An attorney for North Dakota’s Public Service Commission argued Tuesday that the agency cannot consider public safety when issuing pipeline permits, according to a report from the North Dakota Monitor. The statement came during a court hearing over the permit for the Summit Carbon Solutions carbon dioxide pipeline.

Attorney Zachary Pelham, representing the PSC, stated that while the commission must consider public welfare, that does not include safety. “Welfare and safety are two distinct things,” Pelham said during the hearing. The case involves a lawsuit from two counties and a group of landowners seeking to rescind the permit and send the application back to the PSC for further review.

The plaintiffs' attorneys argued that a key flaw in the permit process was the commission's failure to consider evidence on the consequences of a pipeline rupture. Carbon dioxide is a hazardous material, and inhaling it in high concentrations can be fatal. Summit Carbon Solutions developed a plume dispersion model to assess the risks of a rupture, but the model was not made public or included in the PSC's permit record.

Attorney Randall Bakke, representing Burleigh County, said the model would help determine the safety risk posed by the carbon pipeline. Bakke noted that Summit provided the model to some individuals, including a Bismarck developer and an oil industry lobbyist, but did not provide it to attorneys representing stakeholders in the case.

The plume model was also cited as relevant for determining if pipeline setback ordinances passed by Burleigh and Emmons counties could be considered reasonable. These setbacks, which mandate a minimum distance between a pipeline and a residence, form another basis for the permit appeal.

In response, PSC attorney Pelham contended that pipeline safety is strictly a federal issue. When South Central Judicial District Court Judge Jackson Lofgren asked what role the PSC has in regulating a pipeline if it cannot direct its route or ensure its safety, Pelham answered that the commission can consider impacts to state-owned land, the environment, and wildlife. He said commissioners can ask questions about pipeline thickness and shut-off valves but have no authority over those areas.

Bakke argued that Pelham's position "simply defies logic." Attorneys for the landowners also argued the PSC did not properly address insurance liability concerns for landowners in the event of a rupture and that regulators did not adequately analyze the pipeline's financial assurance mechanisms. Judge Jackson Lofgren did not issue a ruling Tuesday.

The hearing highlights the limited scope of state authority over pipeline routing and safety, a regulatory framework that applies to all pipelines crossing North Dakota, including those servicing the Bakken. The outcome could influence how future infrastructure projects for carbon capture, oil, or gas are permitted in the state.

Source

North Dakota Monitor

pipeline regulationpublic service commissionsummit carbon solutionscarbon captureinfrastructure permittingnorth dakotalegal

Share this article

Related Articles

Pipeline & Infrastructure

Pipeline Outage Forces Bakken Producers to Rely on Trucking

North Dakota oil producers are moving crude by truck as a prolonged outage of an Enbridge Inc. pipeline in the state forces them to seek alternatives to avoid shutting in production, according to a Seeking Alpha report. The disruption is creating logistical challenges and increased costs for Bakken operators who typically rely on pipeline networks for efficient transportation to market. While the specific Enbridge line affected was not named in the report, such outages directly impact the takeaway capacity critical to the region's oil fields. "Some producers and marketers are trucking out production to delivery points," the report stated, highlighting the immediate industry response to maintain crude flow. Trucking is a more expensive and less efficient transport method compared to pipelines, squeezing operator margins. The continued outage underscores the vulnerability of regional production to infrastructure disruptions. For Bakken operators, the inability to access a major pipeline necessitates rapid adjustments in...

☀️Morning Wire·Nov 22
Bakken Producers Turn to Trucks Amid Enbridge Pipeline Outage - Bakken Wire
Pipeline & Infrastructure

Bakken Producers Turn to Trucks Amid Enbridge Pipeline Outage

North Dakota oil producers are moving crude by truck as a prolonged outage of Enbridge Inc.'s pipeline in the state continues, according to a Seeking Alpha report. The disruption is forcing operators to seek alternative transportation to avoid shutting in production. "Some producers and marketers are trucking out production to delivery points," the report stated. This shift to trucking represents a significant logistical and economic change for Bakken operators, who typically rely on pipelines for cost-effective transport. The increased reliance on trucking comes with higher costs and logistical challenges compared to pipeline shipments. For Bakken operators and royalty owners, these added expenses can compress margins and complicate daily operations. The ongoing outage highlights the critical nature of pipeline infrastructure for the Williston Basin's oil economy. Pipeline capacity is essential for maintaining steady, economical crude transportation from the wellhead to market. While the specific cause and expected duration of the Enbridge...

🔆Midday Wire·Nov 21
Pipeline & Infrastructure

Enbridge Pipeline Outage Forces Bakken Producers to Truck Crude

North Dakota oil producers are turning to trucks to move crude to market as a continued outage on a key Enbridge pipeline system restricts flows, according to a Bloomberg report cited by Seeking Alpha. The disruption is forcing operators to find alternative transport methods to avoid shutting in production. The shift to trucking represents a significant operational and economic challenge for Bakken producers. Pipeline transport is typically the most cost-effective and efficient method for moving large volumes of crude from the wellhead to refineries and hubs. Relying on trucks increases transportation costs per barrel and introduces logistical complexities. For operators in the Bakken formation, North Dakota's primary oil-producing region, prolonged pipeline constraints can directly impact cash flow and drilling plans. While trucking provides a necessary outlet to keep wells online, sustained use at scale can erode profit margins, especially if the outage continues indefinitely. The specific Enbridge pipeline involved and...

🌅Afternoon Wire·Nov 20